Two people each withdraw $40. Their printed receipts show the same cash dispensed, but the price of the withdrawal may differ. This mini-lab teaches a group to keep the amount taken from the ATM separate from the cost of taking it out, and to stop when a piece of evidence is missing.
Exhibit B: three synthetic scenarios
Invented teaching data. Follow only the amounts shown in the table. Scenario 1 and Scenario 2 describe separate hypothetical trips, not transactions in a participant’s account. For Scenario 3, the operator charge is deliberately unknown. No one needs to enter a PIN, visit a real ATM or share a receipt.
| Scenario | Program fee | Operator charge | Total fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. First eligible trip | $0.00 | $3.25 | $3.25 |
| 2. Later eligible trip | $2.00 | $0.00 | $2.00 |
| 3. Operator amount absent | $2.00 | Not stated | Unknown |
Cover the right column before handing out the exhibit. Ask partners to write two separate answers for each row: “cash received” and “fees.” Then ask what evidence would close Scenario 3. The answer is a verified operator amount for the particular machine or transaction, not an average or a promise borrowed from another location. Use “$2 program fee known; operator charge unknown” as the acceptable interim wording.
Make the error visible
Put a common wrong answer on the board: “Trip 1 is free because the schedule says $0.” Have learners identify exactly what evidence contradicts it. If they still combine cash and fees, redraw the table with separate headings. If someone asks which trip is best in real life, point out that this exhibit provides no information about distance, access, applicable terms or what a cardholder needs. The score is for completing the evidence trail, not for picking a product.
The CFPB’s prepaid-account rule and official interpretations distinguish third-party charges from charges assessed by a provider or on its behalf. The column labels in this lesson reflect that distinction; the sample amounts do not reflect any current product. Start with marking the rule in Exhibit A if the group has not used fee rows before.