On paper, a number can look right even when the reasoning cannot travel to a slightly different example. This scoring sheet is for the explanation, not the learner. Participants can answer by speaking, pointing to a row or writing a sentence. Record which concept to reteach, not who has which card or account.

Print sheet: prompt and four independent marks

Invented example only. In the training schedule, the first completed in-network withdrawal each calendar month has a $0 program fee. A later completed eligible withdrawal has a $2 program fee. An operator’s separate fee might apply, but the prompt gives no amount. Ask: “A second completed in-network withdrawal happens in May. What is known about its price?”

  1. Event: names second completed in-network withdrawal; a generic “ATM visit” is not enough.
  2. Window: identifies May as the calendar-month window and does not guess a payday rule.
  3. Known amount: gives $2 as the program fee, using the named payer or party.
  4. Unknown amount: leaves the operator charge and the total unresolved.

Use the same marking method with a changed event: “The second visit in May was a balance inquiry.” The answer must change. The fictional withdrawal line cannot establish the price of an inquiry. The participant need not name the correct alternate row if the exhibit does not contain it; explaining what is missing is the evidence skill being tested.

Facilitator feedback the class can act on

Right number, wrong window
“Point to when the count starts over. Would two pay deposits change that word?”
Right fee, wrong party
“Whose charge did you name? Which party did the sample leave open?”
Unexpected answer with good evidence
“Read the words you relied on. Is there a second condition that the sentence needs?”

Finish by handing out an unmarked second copy so pairs can try again, not by collecting responses labeled with names or employment details. If a participant asks whether their employer can insist on a payroll card, separate that choice question from the exercise and provide the CFPB’s public payroll-card choice answer; local requirements and personal circumstances are outside the marking task. For the underlying timeline activity, go to the counting-window drill.