A short schedule built around “one free use” is easy to misread if the class has not first asked when the allowance renews. Use two schedules with exactly the same dollar amount, then change only the noun that names the counting window. The class can see which part of the rule moved the answer.

Exhibit C: one change in wording

Fictitious schedules; neither represents any product. Both provide the first completed eligible withdrawal at no program charge and charge $2 for later completed eligible withdrawals in the same window. Schedule C uses a calendar month. Schedule P uses fixed demonstration pay periods of April 19–May 2 and May 3–May 16. An ATM operator charge is outside this particular exercise.

  1. April 25: eligible withdrawal completes.
  2. May 1: eligible withdrawal completes.
  3. May 2: a balance inquiry occurs.
  4. May 3: eligible withdrawal is attempted and fails.
  5. May 4: eligible withdrawal completes.
  6. May 9: eligible withdrawal completes.

Give a reason, not just a tally

For Schedule C, predicted program fees are $0 on April 25 and May 1, then $2 each on May 4 and May 9. For Schedule P, April 25 is free, May 1 costs $2, May 4 is free, and May 9 costs $2. The May 2 and May 3 events do not consume the allowance under the exact words in this invented rule. The exhibit does not assign any other price to those events; attempts and inquiries may have distinct lines in actual disclosures.

Both arrangements produce the same total program fees in this particular sequence, $4. That makes a tidy classroom trap: a participant can arrive at $4 twice with the wrong reasoning. Require an explanation at May 1 and May 4 and have learners draw the boundary before they reveal the answers.

Extension: remove May 9

The new totals are $2 for each schedule again. Now add one completed eligible withdrawal on April 30 before the May events. It falls within April under C and within the first pay period under P; it costs $2 under either, but does not equalize the explanations for May 1 or May 4. To create different totals, remove April 25 and May 9 from the original set. C then charges $2 across its two May withdrawals, while P charges $0 because May 1 and May 4 are first uses in their respective periods.

Use the CFPB model disclosure collection to see how concise fee rows and qualifications are presented. This exercise is about tracking the window in the wording, not claiming that any payroll-card account uses these rules. For practice with naming the trigger itself, see the annotation activity.